HorrorMovieFans.com

Jason wrote:

DancesWithWerewolves wrote:Can I get a ruling on the TV Remake bit (doesn't matter which came first)?

And it seems everyone's cool if we haven't seen the original to count, so I'll go edit the Masque of the Red Death in...

Edit: Looks like 1964's Red Death is the first film version, lol. So nevermind on that

IT should count. It's a movie, imo.

But the original is a TV miniseries, which is why I asked.

DancesWithWerewolves wrote:

Jason wrote:

DancesWithWerewolves wrote:Can I get a ruling on the TV Remake bit (doesn't matter which came first)?

And it seems everyone's cool if we haven't seen the original to count, so I'll go edit the Masque of the Red Death in...

Edit: Looks like 1964's Red Death is the first film version, lol. So nevermind on that

IT should count. It's a movie, imo.

But the original is a TV miniseries, which is why I asked.

That's what I mean. I count the OG as a movie. And even if it wasn't, you can only rank the remake. Which is clearly a movie. lol.

Jason wrote:

DancesWithWerewolves wrote:

Jason wrote:

DancesWithWerewolves wrote:Can I get a ruling on the TV Remake bit (doesn't matter which came first)?

And it seems everyone's cool if we haven't seen the original to count, so I'll go edit the Masque of the Red Death in...

Edit: Looks like 1964's Red Death is the first film version, lol. So nevermind on that

IT should count. It's a movie, imo.

But the original is a TV miniseries, which is why I asked.

That's what I mean. I count the OG as a movie. And even if it wasn't, you can only rank the remake. Which is clearly a movie. lol.

I'm fine with that justification.

It's more than that, damnit. Is Batman 89 considered a remake?

Reign in Blood wrote:It's more than that, damnit. Is Batman 89 considered a remake?

as d chose to assemble his list, he'd probably count it here, if it was also horror.

zombie wrote:

Reign in Blood wrote:It's more than that, damnit. Is Batman 89 considered a remake?

as d chose to assemble his list, he'd probably count it here, if it was also horror.

Are you sure? I don't think he's so sure, I got D scratching his chonies thinking if it should count.

Reign in Blood wrote:It's more than that, damnit. Is Batman 89 considered a remake?

Nope. But that superhero stuff winds up being an exception because they're not actually adapting stories, just bringing the characters on screen and making their own stories.

Unless it's actually adapting Batman: The Dark Knight Returns, The Long Halloween, or other storylines like that getting repeatedly made, then no it doesn't count.

If they were to use Pennywise again, remolded him in a new continuity, but didn't reference the book at all other than using the character, I'd have a hard time swallowing it as a remake.

Casino Royale would count as a remake, because it's technically been done before, even though the first time around was a parody film.

Reign in Blood wrote:

zombie wrote:

Reign in Blood wrote:It's more than that, damnit. Is Batman 89 considered a remake?

as d chose to assemble his list, he'd probably count it here, if it was also horror.

Are you sure? I don't think he's so sure, I got D scratching his chonies thinking if it should count.

if no, it's because it's only adapting characters and not a specific story. but possible you're right.

I'm ultimately leaving the decision up to Head though since he's running the show. If he wants to leave it exclusively to movie-to-movie remakes or not.

Head don't know shit, we're leaving nothing up to him.

If it's by vote, so far it's 3-1 (I'm abstaining since I'm only going to react to the outcome)

Who is the one dissenter!

Reign in Blood wrote:Who is the one dissenter!

You? Unless I'm confused about what side you're falling on lol

lol, nah, I'm just trying not to justify it. Just like you, something about it didn't feel right, but fuck it, it fits as a remake.

Unanimous!

Since we aren't comparing them to the originals...

The Thing
Silent Night
Black Xmas
Invaders From Mars(if it's considered horror, it's usually listed as sci-fi horror, but I always just considered it sci-fi, your call)
Dawn of the Dead
The Hills Have Eyes
IT
Piranha 3D
The Fly
The Crazies

I'm not really a fan of the last two on the list, but they're ok.

1. The Thing
2. The Blob
3. Dawn of the Dead
4. The Fly
5. The Evil Dead
6. Night of the Living Dead
7. IT
8. The Hills Have Eyes
9. Piranha 3D
10. Let Me In

I thought I rememebered Slaughter loving Pirahna 3D....hrmm.

Slaughterhouserock wrote:Since we aren't comparing them to the originals...

My list would be very short when it comes to remakes better than the originals

DancesWithWerewolves wrote:

Slaughterhouserock wrote:Since we aren't comparing them to the originals...

My list would be very short when it comes to remakes better than the originals

i've got four on my list, that i consider better than the originals. and a couple of others that are almost on par with the originals.