2024 October Challenge Discussion Thread

[Reign in Blood]

I've never heard of this Ed Gale dude, friggin legend, he played Howard the Duck, the original Chucky, Dwarf in Phantasm 2, Station in Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey, and the Doll in Dolly Dearest. I'd shoot the shit with that little guy, fucking A.

[Jigsaw]

Visiting Wes Craven's New Nightmare once more.

Will it break 7/10? Let's find out fam.

[Jason]

I've never heard of this Ed Gale dude, friggin legend, he played Howard the Duck, the original Chucky, Dwarf in Phantasm 2, Station in Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey, and the Doll in Dolly Dearest. I'd shoot the shit with that little guy, fucking A.

Damn, and he played Pikachu in the Norm Show. He's done it all.

[Jason]

Visiting Wes Craven's New Nightmare once more.

Will it break 7/10? Let's find out fam.

Heather Langenkamp hotness propels it to an even 7.

[Jason]

This movie is sufficiently creepy.

[Reign in Blood]

I've never heard of this Ed Gale dude, friggin legend, he played Howard the Duck, the original Chucky, Dwarf in Phantasm 2, Station in Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey, and the Doll in Dolly Dearest. I'd shoot the shit with that little guy, fucking A.

Damn, and he played Pikachu in the Norm Show. He's done it all.

I'll be damned, right to your heart. And he did Baywatch, I bet he banged half the cast! Let's get him on Havok's show, asap.

[Tiggnutz]

Watching Joe Bob's showing of Cemetery Man

[Jason]

This movie is a trip. It's no Dolls, but golly. Definitely unique enough.

[Reign in Blood]

Better than Annabelle?

[Tiggnutz]

Better than Annabelle?

And Dolls

[Jason]

Better than Annabelle?

I don't even remember if I've seen Annabelle for sure. And it seems like I would likely favor it over Annabelle if I hadn't, anyway.

[Jason]

Better than Annabelle?

And Dolls

[Tiggnutz]

For some reason I consider Dolls, Dolly Dearest and Demonic Toys all the same movie

[Jason]

For some reason I consider Dolls, Dolly Dearest and Demonic Toys all the same movie

Probably should rewatch all three.

[Tiggnutz]

For some reason I consider Dolls, Dolly Dearest and Demonic Toys all the same movie

Probably should rewatch all three.

Maybe

[zombie]

For some reason I consider Dolls, Dolly Dearest and Demonic Toys all the same movie

if so, dolls is the best version of that movie.

[Jason]

I think Demonic Toys 2 had a possessed lady midget if I recall correctly.

[Jason]

How do you score Dolly Dearest? Creepy suspense was gonna give it a strong 4/5 stars and in the low-mid 8s for a decimal grading, however, the personality reveal of the doll was a little silly. But the soundtrack is great and it really had some strong moments. On a decimal grade how do you score that? The silliness is gonna drop it to a 3.5/5 stars, but closer to 4 than 3, so 7.2?

I'm going 7.2.

[Reign in Blood]

Needs to be closer to 8, 7.6.

[Jason]

Needs to be closer to 8, 7.6.

That'd make it a weak 4/5 stars. It's getting a 3.5/5 which means it'd have to fall between a 6.5/10 and a 7.4/10 and it's on the stronger end of a 3.5/5 so it'd have to be between a 7.0 and a 7.4 so I'm going 7.2.

Letter grading and non-decimal grading is for rookies! We're professionals here.